| Platinum | The Flagler Fish Co |
| Gold | Anthony's Fresh Fish |
| Silver | The Anchor |
| Bronze | High Tides At Snack Jack |
| Top Pick | Fancy Sushi |
| Top Pick | Oceanside Beach Grille |
| Top Pick | Sushi 99 |
| Top Pick | The Brown Dog |
| Top Pick | The Golden Lion Cafe |
| Top Pick | The Net by George |
| The Landing Strip Tavern |